⟵ 08 Scale (Narrative) · Contents · 08 Scale (Problem Set) ⟶
Scale: Engineering Notes
“If you are reading this straight through, you can skip this section and lose nothing essential to the story. These notes are for the operators, engineers, and technicians who need to do the math.”
Why this matters in the field
Scale is not mysterious. It’s an energy bargain and a mass-balance problem:
- Cycles determine how hard you crowd ions together (bulk driving force).
- Temperature determines where solubility collapses (heat exchangers).
- Indices estimate CaCO₃ scaling pressure (not deposit rate).
- Kinetics (residence time, surfaces, inhibitors, turbulence) determines whether that pressure becomes a deposit.
Core Tools & Constants
| Constant / Formula | Value |
|---|---|
| 1 gal water | ≈ 8.34 lb |
| meq/L from mg/L as CaCO₃ | mg/L as CaCO₃ ÷ 50 |
| Calcium Concentration (mg/L as Ca²⁺) | (Calcium Hardness as CaCO₃ ÷ 100) × 40 |
| COC (conductivity) | Tower cond. / Makeup cond. |
| COC (chloride) | [Cl⁻] Tower / [Cl⁻] Makeup |
| Ion at tower | Ion at makeup × COC |
| LSI | pH − pHₛ |
| RSI | 2 × pHₛ − pH |
| PSI | 2 × (pHs) - pHeq |
| pHeq (empirical) | 1.465 × log₁₀(Alk) + 4.54 |
| pHₛ | (9.3 + A + B) − (C + D) |
Predicting Scale: The Indices
Scale indices do not predict outcomes. They describe thermodynamic pressure. LSI / RSI / PSI estimate CaCO₃ saturation bias only. They do not predict deposition rate, deposit thickness, or heat-transfer impact. They say nothing about CaSO₄, SiO₂, Ca₃(PO₄)₂, or MgSiO₃.
In practice, scale indices are most useful as comparative tools, not absolute limits. The absolute number matters far less than how it moves.
The Langelier Saturation Index
The Langelier Saturation Index (LSI) estimates whether calcium carbonate (CaCO₃) will tend to dissolve or precipitate in a given water.
LSI compares the actual pH of the water to the theoretical pH at calcium carbonate equilibrium (pHs) - the point at which Ca²⁺ and CO₃²⁻ are in balance between dissolution and precipitation.
LSI = pH - pHs
Calculating pHs:
pHs = (9.3+A+B)−(C+D)
Where:
- A = (log10(TDS)−1) / 10
- B = −13.12 × log10(T+273) + 34.55
- C = log10(Ca hardness as CaCO3) − 0.4
- D = log10(Total Alkalinity as CaCO3)1
Inputs:
- TDS in mg/L (or use conductivity-to-TDS estimate if needed)
- Temperature in °C
- Calcium hardness and alkalinity in mg/L as CaCO₃
Interpretation:
- LSI < 0: CaCO₃ dissolution favored
- LSI = 0: equilibrium; no net scaling or dissolution
- LSI > 0: CaCO₃ precipitation favored
The Ryznar Stability Index
The Ryznar Stability Index (RSI) estimates the actual behavior of water based on field observations. The pHs value is calculated in the same way as the LSI, but the output is changed.
RSI = 2pHs - pH
Interpretation:
- RSI < 6: scale-forming tendency
- RSI 6–7: borderline / “balanced” zone
- RSI > 7: CaCO₃ dissolving tendency (often more corrosive)
The Puckorius Scaling Index
The Puckorius Scaling Index (PSI) refines things further by introducing buffering capacity: how much the water’s pH can actually change during scale formation. It uses the equilibrium pH after precipitation instead of the measured pH, acknowledging that chemistry in an operating cooling tower does not stand still.
This difference in interpretation can produce significant divergence from the other models. PSI is particularly useful for high-alkalinity waters and cooling towers where CO₂ is constantly being stripped out.
PSI = 2 × (pHs) - pHeq
The pHs value is calculated in the same way as the LSI. The pHeq is the equilibrium pH the water tends toward after CaCO₃ precipitation/CO₂ effects are considered:
pHeq = 1.465 × log10(Total Alkalinity as CaCO3) + 4.542
Interpretation:
- PSI < ~6: scale forming
- PSI 6–7: borderline / “balanced” zone
- PSI > 7: dissolving tendency
The Scaling Salts
The narrative section dealt in generalities. These are the specific salts that commonly matter most, and the levers that govern each.
| Salt | Primary Levers | Scaling Behavior | Key System Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| CaCO₃ | Concentration, pH, temperature | Favored by high cycles, high pH, and high temperature; exhibits inverse solubility | Cooling towers, condenser tubes, heat exchangers, RO membranes, boiler hardness excursions |
| CaSO₄ | Concentration, temperature | Much more soluble than CaCO₃, but dangerous at high cycles, pH is usually secondary | Cooling towers using sulfuric acid, RO membranes, high-sulfate waters |
| SiO₂ | Concentration, pH, temperature | Amorphous silica favored by high cycles, low temperatures (potential to form mag silicate at high pH, high temperature) | Cooling towers, reverse osmosis |
| Ca₃(PO₄)₂ | Concentration, pH, temperature | Strongly favored by elevated pH and temperature; often caused by phosphate release or overfeed | Cooling towers with phosphate treatment, systems with stressed phosphate/phosphonate chemistry |
| MgSiO₃ | Concentration, pH, temperature | Favored by high pH, high temperature | High-pH cooling towers, boilers with hardness/silica contamination, high-cycle silica-rich systems |
Calcium Carbonate - CaCO₃
Calcium carbonate is the most common scaling salt in industrial water systems. Formation depends on calcium concentration and carbonate availability, which is governed strongly by pH. It exhibits inverse solubility, making it especially dangerous at heat-transfer surfaces where temperature is highest. Cooling towers are vulnerable because evaporation concentrates calcium and alkalinity, while carbon dioxide stripping drives pH upward. Calcium carbonate responds to all three major levers: concentration, pH, and temperature. LSI, RSI, and PSI are designed specifically around this salt.
Calcium Sulfate - CaSO₄
Calcium sulfate formation depends primarily on calcium and sulfate concentration. pH is usually a secondary lever. Calcium sulfate is far more soluble than calcium carbonate, so it often receives less attention at low cycles. But systems using sulfuric acid for pH control can accumulate large sulfate loads, and high cycles can push the water toward calcium sulfate saturation. Once formed, calcium sulfate deposits are dense, hard, and resistant to normal acid cleaning. Prevention is far easier than removal.
Silica - SiO₂
Silica usually exists in water as dissolved silicic acid, Si(OH)₄, a neutral species that contributes little to conductivity. This makes silica dangerous because it can concentrate quietly while conductivity-based control appears normal. Practical limits are often treated around 120–180 mg/L as SiO₂ in cooling systems, depending on pH, temperature, magnesium, residence time, and inhibitor chemistry. Once silica exceeds its practical limit, it can polymerize into amorphous, glassy deposits that are extraordinarily difficult to remove. Standard calcium carbonate indices do not account for silica. Monitoring requires direct silica analysis.
Calcium Phosphate - Ca₃(PO₄)₂
Calcium phosphate appears most often in systems using phosphate-containing treatment programs. Polyphosphates can hydrolyze into orthophosphate at elevated temperature, and phosphonates can degrade under strong oxidizing or thermal stress. Orthophosphate then reacts with calcium, especially at elevated pH, to form low-solubility calcium phosphate deposits. This is one of the more frustrating forms of scale because the chemistry added to prevent deposition can become the source of deposition when overstressed or overfed.
Magnesium Silicate - MgSiO₃
Magnesium silicate deposits form when magnesium and silica coexist under high-pH, high-temperature conditions. In real systems, these deposits are often mixed and hydrated rather than a pure, neat MgSiO₃ crystal. The practical risk is still the same: glassy, adherent deposits that are difficult to remove once established. These deposits are most likely in high-pH cooling systems, high-cycle operation with silica-rich makeup, or boiler systems where hardness and silica control have failed.
⟵ 08 Scale (Narrative) · Contents · 08 Scale (Problem Set) ⟶
Footnotes
-
W. F. Langelier, “The Analytical Control of Anti-Corrosion Water Treatment,” Journal of the American Water Works Association, vol. 28, no. 10 (1936), pp. 1500 to 1521. Confirm the citation details at time of publication. ↩
-
P. R. Puckorius and J. M. Brooke, “A New Practical Index for Calcium Carbonate Scale Prediction in Cooling Tower Systems,” Corrosion (NACE), vol. 47 (1991), pp. 280 to 284. Confirm the citation details at time of publication. ↩